Estimate project
← All posts

Don't replicate successful architectures

A frequent software architecture mistake is mechanically reproducing successful architectures while ignoring the specific needs and context of a project – here is why that is a problem.

8 min read
MicroservicesArchitectureSoftware DevelopmentBusiness Strategy

A frequent mistake in software architecture is mechanically reproducing successful architectures while ignoring the specific needs and context of a project. Many companies, for instance, attempt to recreate the architecture of successful firms such as Netflix without asking whether it actually suits them.

Keep in mind that most companies operate at a different scale and have different requirements than Netflix. Every architecture should be shaped around the particular goals and requirements of its project. Mechanically reproducing successful architectures can result in needless complexity and inefficiency.

Relevance

Architectural design has no universal answer, and a one-size-fits-all approach simply does not work. The best software solutions come from tackling real problems, not from chasing an idealized picture.

What companies really need are robust, simple, and predictable solutions that are easy to adapt, develop, and maintain. It is similar to building cars: throwing in every available piece of engineering would make no sense without weighing cost, servicing, time to market, and what users actually need, such as safety and resilience.

Architectural thinking should revolve around business needs. An architect has to thoroughly grasp the business’s context, vision, strategic plans, and history, and that understanding should be visible in the system’s architecture. The architecture ought to tell the business’s story, showing not just how it works but also why it works that way.

Simplicity

Keep things simple. Don’t solve problems you do not have yet. Know your scale, as well as your team’s skills and experience. Concentrate on your particular business niche and keep your tech stack reasonably simple.

When choosing between mature and cutting-edge technologies, take into account things like how critical the project is and whether support is available. Proven technologies are usually the safer bet and reduce risk, but sometimes new ones are unavoidable. In those cases, architects should make well-grounded decisions that reflect the project’s specific requirements.

Don’t try to build for millions of users from day one. Many successful companies, such as Amazon and eBay, rewrote their systems several times over the years. Companies that overengineer their systems for customers they do not yet have frequently never become known–they fail in the market. Find your strengths and make use of them. Tackling only the problems you actually face shortens the product’s time to market.

You may not need microservices right at the start. Their main purpose is independent deployment; any other advantages tend to be side effects rather than the actual goal.

Turn to microservices only when no other workable option remains. They are neither simple nor cheap, and keeping them running takes substantial operational effort. They also bring a lot of extra complexity solely to make independent deployment possible.

More and more companies are abandoning microservices because of their cost and complexity. A modular monolith is very often enough, and it is easier to extend, evolve, and refactor. If it is built sensibly, turning it into full-blown microservices later is fairly straightforward.

Evolution

Over time, you and your team will keep accumulating knowledge. There is no way to foresee every challenge you will face, so accept that uncertainty and incomplete knowledge. It is perfectly normal for an architecture to be imperfect and to change. Architecture is a dynamic rather than static process that calls for an iterative and incremental approach. Accept that your knowledge is never complete; every decision may turn out to be temporary, pending new insights. Treat it as a continuous process.

Challenges and room for improvement will never disappear. Don’t strive for a final state in which everything is finished, because you will never reach it. Rather, grow together with the business, accepting that you cannot have every answer in advance.

Postpone decisions when needed. In fact, the whole point is to delay every decision for as long as you can. If you don’t know what the final decision will be, design things so that changing your mind is easy.

Don’t try to future-proof your architecture, because it can pull your attention away from today’s problems. The future cannot be predicted, and trying to do so can do harm. Concentrate on the problem at hand and think just one step ahead, not ten. Universal solutions only add complexity and seldom work out.

Ongoing learning and experience, gained both inside and outside the organization, are essential for building your skills and expanding what you can do.

Architectural decisions should be informed by understanding and experience. An iterative and incremental approach gives you flexibility and the chance to correct mistakes. Begin with your best guess given what you know now, and refine the architecture as new information arrives. It is important to separate the well-understood aspects of the system from those that are not.

Give yourself permission to make mistakes and learn from them. This process of discovery is key to understanding the constraints and dependencies within an architecture.

Constraints

Every architectural choice involves trade-offs. Saying ‘yes’ to one thing automatically means saying ‘no’ to another. The idea underscores that nothing is free.

Moreover, every action – including deciding not to act – has consequences. Bear in mind that nothing in architecture lives in isolation; everything interacts with, and is shaped by, the context around it.

Developers frequently look for the perfect solution to a problem, yet such a solution hardly ever exists. Favoring some values always means giving ground on others. That is why knowing what to concentrate on matters so much: solutions tailored to a specific problem usually deliver more value than generic ones.

Be aware of the limits of your knowledge so you avoid overconfidence and the problems it brings.

Every decision and every technology has a price. No solution is free. Even trying to stay independent of a particular tool or technology costs something, often adding complexity and making the solution less clear and readable.

Modularization

Modularization is a cornerstone of software development that stresses well-defined boundaries, information hiding, encapsulation of business logic, and data ownership. Simple components let us assemble ever more complex systems. It is the main way to keep complexity and cognitive overload under control.

Getting the module size right is essential. Splitting things too finely can cause problems with coordination and cooperation, dependency management, and sharing knowledge and data.

The aim is to build systems that meet today’s needs while leaving room to split or merge modules later without affecting the rest of the system. Such an approach is usually easier to achieve in a monolithic architecture.

Complex systems may look attractive, but they tend to create complications. Simpler systems, by contrast, can be scaled up into more versatile and robust architectures.

Attention should go not only to technology but also to semantic boundaries–establishing clear language, responsibilities, and the flow of data and control. Modules should strive for autonomy and take care of the data they need.

Still, bear in mind that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to modularization. It is a process that enriches the system’s language and makes meaningful conversations about it possible.

Perspective

The central idea of a module is to conceal as many details as possible from the outside. Whatever a module exposes forms its public API, which becomes hard to change once other modules rely on it.

Designing these contracts carefully and keeping decisions hidden inside the module leaves room to adjust the design and assumptions, making it easier for the system to evolve through refactoring.

The power of a module comes from its internals being invisible from the outside, with all interaction going through its public API. Thanks to that, the inside can change without impacting other modules, and the module’s boundaries stay intact.

This modular approach also shapes how we think and talk about these components. A clearly defined public interface for each module makes its role, responsibilities, and data ownership explicit. Designing modules around their contracts produces a system whose components depend on each other less and fit together better.

Keeping a system’s architecture in good shape means understanding it at several levels, as the C4 model illustrates. You need to identify the collaborating components at each level and know which level they belong to. Unknowingly mixing levels can cause trouble.

Grasping a system’s relationships and levels is essential for well-informed architectural decisions.

Context

It is vital to see that a system is more than just code. It covers a range of practices and elements, such as deployment strategies, documentation, continuous integration and deployment (CI/CD), organizational culture, communication, and testing.

All of these are critical to whether a software project succeeds and functions well. Advanced techniques such as canary deployments and feature flags are also essential for keeping deployments low-risk. Likewise, meaningful production logs and metrics are indispensable for making informed decisions.

Running high-performing systems hinges on fast, high-quality feedback, which demands a serious investment in automated testing. Automated tests do more than speed up feedback and raise code quality; they also act as executable documentation. Such documentation is extremely valuable for understanding existing code, making changes easier, and improving system design.

Code can act as documentation, but it should not be the only source. It frequently lacks the broader context and the reasoning behind design choices, and recording and tracking that reasoning can be tedious.

Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) address this problem. ADRs are a lightweight, readily available way to record and share why architectural choices were made. They are essential for preserving a clear historical context of decisions, so that the reasoning behind them is understood and kept throughout the project’s lifecycle.

Summary

You need to keep watching your environment and surroundings, keep up with new technologies and approaches, and stay eager to learn. At the same time, a healthy dose of skepticism toward new trends is wise. Always put first how relevant the software is to the business it serves. What truly makes software great is how closely it fits and supports the business goals it was built for.